Classic Rock Resilience: 5 Bands That Prospered with New Frontmen

In the world of classic rock, a lead singer often finds themselves at the center of attention, which can sometimes lead to tension and conflict within the band. As some vocalists chase after solo pursuits or as interpersonal issues arise, a change in the frontman inevitably happens for some bands. Though such a shift can threaten to disrupt the group's creative flow, there are classic rock acts that have not only survived but flourished after a lineup change at the mic.

1. Pink Floyd's Syd Barrett to David Gilmour and Beyond

Pink Floyd's inception in the psychedelic rock scene was colored largely by the creative influence of their original lead singer and guitarist, Syd Barrett. Hits like 'See Emily Play' and 'Arnold Layne' from their dynamic debut album The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (1967) illustrated Barrett's significance. However, Barrett's erratic behavior, intensified by drug usage, led to his departure in early 1968. The band smoothly transitioned to a more atmospheric and conceptual sound, with vocals shared among David Gilmour, Roger Waters, and Rick Wright, successfully maintaining their artistry post-Barrett.

2. The Evolution of Steely Dan's Vocals

Steely Dan's debut album, Can't Buy a Thrill (1972), featured Donald Fagen and David Palmer on shared lead vocal duties, with Palmer's voice gracing the iconic track 'Dirty Work.' However, Fagen's distinct vocal delivery proved to be a better fit for the duo's sardonic lyricism, and by their next album in 1973, Fagen took over as the band's primary vocalist, a role he retained through Steely Dan's illustrious career.

3. AC/DC: From Bon Scott to Brian Johnson

AC/DC's original lead singer, Bon Scott, brought an inimitable squeal and mischievous energy to the band's early image. Following his untimely death in 1980, AC/DC pressed forward with Brian Johnson stepping in to provide a grittier vocal sound. This pivotal change occurred as the band reached a turning point, with Johnson's debut album Back in Black becoming one of history's best-selling records.

4. Van Halen's Vocalist Saga: David Lee Roth and Sammy Hagar

The transition from flamboyant showman David Lee Roth to the equally successful Sammy Hagar is one of rock's most talked-about vocalist changes. Van Halen's seismic shifts in frontman haven't impeded their ability to adapt and continue to reign as a powerhouse in hard rock, with fans still debating their favorite era.

5. The Moody Blues: A Transformation of Sound

Beginning with the British Invasion hit 'Go Now' in 1964, The Moody Blues charted their course to stardom with Denny Laine at the helm. The band faced a slump after Laine's departure in 1966, but the arrival of Justin Hayward and John Lodge saw them pivot to a more symphonic rock direction, returning to prominence and enjoying sustained success for years to come, while Laine found a fresh start with Paul McCartney's Wings.

resilience, change, success