Potential Replacements for Katy Perry on American Idol

After a notable seven-season stint as a judge on American Idol, Katy Perry has announced her departure following season 22. She broke the news on Jimmy Kimmel Live!, expressing her desire to explore new projects, particularly focusing on her music career. Perry reflects positively on her time on the show, feeling a strong connection with America through it but now seeks to follow her personal creative rhythm.

As the show prepares for season 23, speculation is rife about who might fill Perry's vacant seat at the judge's table. Perry herself hinted at creating space for her 'new wingspan,' teasing the intrigue around her replacement. With a wealth of female talent having either guest judged or mentored on the series, a few names stand out as strong contenders for the role.

In season nine, Avril Lavigne graced the auditions as a guest judge, sharing the panel with Katy Perry. That season also saw Shania Twain, Mary J. Blige, Victoria Beckham, and Kristin Chenoweth try their hand at judging. There has been talk about former judges like Jennifer Lopez, Nicki Minaj, Mariah Carey, Kara DioGuardi, and Ellen DeGeneres possibly returning to the judge's chair.

1. Alanis Morissette

Alanis Morissette and Ed Sheeran joined as guest judges and mentors in season 21 while Perry and fellow judge Lionel Richie were away. Morissette's sharp insights and industry experience made a strong impression on fans, who started campaigning for her to take on the role full-time. This followed some social media backlash against Perry for comments she made on the show that some viewers found offensive.

2. Carrie Underwood

A previous winner of American Idol, Carrie Underwood, has maintained a relationship with the show, returning as a mentor. Given her busy schedule with tours and a Las Vegas residency, any potential involvement would hinge on timing. However, her residency concludes in August 2024, potentially aligning with the American Idol filming schedule.

3. Jennifer Lopez

Jennifer Lopez, having served as a judge in past seasons, speaks fondly of how the show helped reinvent her career during a personal and professional crossroads. Now, with a new album on the horizon and her previous tenure on the show, she could be a valuable addition to the panel once again.

4. Paula Abdul

The original judging trio could see a revival with Paula Abdul, who has made guest appearances since her official departure in 2009. Abdul has a rich history with the show, and her comeback, even temporary, during the show's anniversary celebrations nods to her lasting legacy within the American Idol brand.

replacement, judge, mentor